In July 2025, 16 households on the 1300 block of West Newport Avenue signed a letter to PLD Homes. The developer had bought the century-old greystone at 1300 W. Newport in a private sale, and the neighbors offered to pay for a redesign if the builder would keep the facade. Block Club Chicago reported that the letter said the neighbors supported redevelopment. What they objected to was a full teardown and a third story out front on a block where the north side keeps a steady two-story profile.
The building came down. By April 2026, Chicago YIMBY reported a three-story-plus-basement, two-unit building going up on the lot, laid out as a duplex-down and a duplex-up. On November 5, 2026, the Commission on Chicago Landmarks voted to move forward with a preliminary designation for the Eddy-Cornelia-Newport District, which takes in that block and its neighbors. Ald. Bennett Lawson reported the vote in his November 12 newsletter.
For a buyer comparing West Lakeview two-flats with the rest of the North Side, the more useful story is how these blocks came to look so alike. That consistency is what a buyer here is paying for, and a small circle of builders working to a shared standard set it more than a century ago.
A Standard Written Into the Deeds
The Department of Planning and Development's preliminary report covers 1200 to 1345 W. Eddy Street, W. Cornelia Avenue and W. Newport Avenue, plus 3412 to 3545 N. Lakewood Avenue and the even side of 3412 to 3544 N. Racine Avenue. It counts 197 structures built there between 1901 and 1928. Nearly all are two-flats, three-flats and apartment buildings, and one is a cottage.
At a January community meeting, city preservation planner Kandalyn Hahn told neighbors the area "presents an unusually high degree of architectural uniformity," Block Club Chicago reported. She said many of the buildings were built as rentals for German immigrant families who worked in nearby factories, and that early deed restrictions required masonry construction, consistent setbacks and minimum building costs. Because the deeds demanded brick or stone, an even setback and a minimum spend, the fronts still line up today.
The Builders and Architects Behind the Facades
The report names the people behind the buildings. Repeat builders include John McLaren, the Oliver brothers, Martin H. Serum, and J.C. and Bertha Cockburn. Edward Benson, Paul Hansen, George F. Lovdall, Oscar Johnson, William E. Gauger, Frank O. DeMoney, Louis M. Mitchell and James Burns each designed more than one building here. Lovdall also designed the district's only cottage, at 1241 W. Eddy. Staff singled out Julius H. Huber's three-flat at 1313 W. Cornelia and Joseph Molitor's ornamented two-flat at 1217 W. Cornelia. On a listing sheet for one of these blocks, the builder and architect on that roster are the closest thing a two-flat has to a provenance.
How the Blocks Have Changed Since
Most of the original stock is still standing. Of the 197 structures, the report counts 13 demolished, about 6.6%, and three significantly altered. Much of the change has happened behind the stone. The 1300 W. Newport neighbors' letter said many buildings on the block had been converted to single-family homes or two-flat layouts, and one neighbor told Block Club that most houses there had been gut rehabbed while keeping their original facades.
That matches a wider Lake View pattern. DePaul's Institute for Housing Studies tracked assessor records from 2013 to 2019 and found that Lake View lost 459 two-to-four-unit parcels in that period, totaling 1,163 units. About 58.6% of those parcels became single-family homes. Small buildings still trade often here. DePaul counts 196 single-family sales and 124 sales of two-to-four-unit buildings in Lake View during calendar 2025. DePaul's price index for the combined Lake View/Lincoln Park single-family submarket shows prices up 10.6% year over year in the second quarter of 2026.
Those numbers explain the pressure on the 1300 block of Newport. With single-family values rising, a two-flat here attracts bids from owner-occupants who plan to rehab and from builders who plan to start over, and the new building at 1300 W. Newport came from the second group. The same thing has happened elsewhere in the neighborhood. Preservation Chicago, citing Chicago YIMBY, reported that the greystone at 3617 N. Magnolia was demolished in March 2026. A new-construction permit was then issued on July 10, 2026, for the 1906 greystone next door at 3619 N. Magnolia. In his November 12 newsletter, Ald. Lawson wrote that "we've seen an increase in demolitions in this neighborhood, with several historic buildings lost just this year."
What Matching Streets Have Been Worth in Chicago
Owners inside the boundary don't all agree on the vote. Crain's Chicago Business reported in March that the pushback came largely from residents whose own blocks were less uniform. One resident told Crain's he believed landmark status could cap his home's value by making redevelopment less attractive to builders. Lawson wrote that owners have questions about renovations, property values and future development.
Chicago has evidence on how matching historic streets trade, though it is dated. Douglas S. Noonan's 2007 study of attached-home sales in Chicago from 1990 to 1999 found that properties inside landmark districts sold at a 3% to 5% premium over comparable properties in his cross-sectional models. Noonan cautioned that the premium can't be credited to designation alone. His repeat-sales analysis found limited and mixed evidence, including roughly a 2% price increase for each additional landmark designated in a home's block group.
Those results come from a different decade and a different market, so they can't predict what these 197 buildings will sell for in 2027. What they show is that Chicago buyers have paid somewhat more for homes on intact historic streets, and that the study couldn't separate how much of that came from the street and how much from the designation. On Eddy, Cornelia and Newport, the street goes back to the deed restrictions and the builders named above.
Lake View has plenty of blocks with this kind of history. The community area already has six landmark districts. Among them are Alta Vista Terrace, designated in 1971; Hawthorne Place, in 1996; Oakdale Avenue, in 2006; and Surf-Pine Grove, in 2007. The designation report for Alta Vista Terrace describes 40 houses. An earlier Newport Avenue District, designated February 9, 2005, is separate from the Eddy-Cornelia-Newport proposal.
The Next Date on the Calendar
The Commission's next meeting is Thursday, December 3, when the Commissioner of Planning and Development is expected to give an update on the district from a planning perspective. Lawson's newsletter says consent letters to property owners and a public hearing will follow. The official records are the city's preliminary report and the 44th Ward's district page. Our Lakeview neighborhood guide covers the streets around the district.
If a greystone or brick flat between Roscoe and Addison is on your list, Jonathon Spradling and the Spradling | Roberts team can walk Eddy, Cornelia and Newport with you and compare each building with recent two-flat sales nearby. Schedule a private consultation through our buyers page or request a home valuation.